Category Archives: Development

Mongolia to Take Action to Address Corruption



Posted by , , ,

During its regular session on March 14, 2024, the Cabinet of Mongolia made a significant step forward in the fight against corruption by supporting the submission of a draft Resolution to the State Great Khural of Mongolia for approval.

The draft Resolution outlines the implementation of an Action Plan for the Implementation of the National Anti-Corruption Program. the Resolution aims to establish an effective legal framework to combat corruption and encourage public trust in government. The newly proposed resolution for implementing the national anti-corruption program is a much-needed initiative to address the misuse of power and authority.

The draft Resolution outlines 290 measures to be implemented between 2023 and 2030, aimed at achieving the 11 goals and 48 objectives of the National Anti-Corruption Program, as set out in 2023 Resolution No. 59 of the State Great Khural. The success of this program hinges on the active participation and cooperation of all stakeholders, including the public and private sectors, civil society organizations, international organizations, the media, and citizens. The anticipated outcomes of this program are promising. A yearly decline in corruption levels is expected under the plan, leading to an expanded state budget, increased public trust in public organizations, rising citizen income, and a strengthened culture of zero tolerance for corruption. Furthermore, a more robust whistle-blowing system will be established, providing a crucial avenue for reporting and addressing corrupt activities.

Official corruption is a pervasive problem in many Asian countries, undermining the rule of law, hindering economic development, and eroding public trust in institutions. Corruption takes various forms, including bribery, embezzlement, nepotism, and cronyism. It affects all levels of government, from local administrations to national agencies, and can influence decision-making in areas such as business regulations, public procurement, and law enforcement.

The consequences of official corruption are far-reaching. It distorts markets, creating an uneven playing field for businesses and discouraging foreign investment. It also undermines the delivery of essential public services, such as education, healthcare, and infrastructure. Corruption can lead to inefficiencies, waste, and misallocation of resources, further exacerbating poverty and inequality. Moreover, it can fuel social unrest and political instability, as citizens become disillusioned with their governments and demand accountability.

The root causes of official corruption in Asian countries are complex and multifaceted. Some of the key factors include weak institutions, lack of transparency and accountability, and cultural norms that tolerate or even encourage corrupt behavior. In many cases, low salaries and inadequate resources for public officials create incentives for them to engage in corrupt activities. Additionally, complex regulatory systems and opaque decision-making processes can create opportunities for corruption to thrive.

A Mongolian perspective on Public-Private Partnerships Development



Posted by ,

Since the Law of Mongolia on Concessions was adopted in 2010, it has established a legal framework for public-private partnership by granting concessions to private investors to use existing infrastructure facilities owned by the state, and to construct new infrastructure facilities for the purpose of providing services.

However, the current Concessions law is inadequate to meet the needs of fundamental principles of public-private partnership such as planning, granting and effective risk and debt management.

The implementation of the Concessions law raised the following issues:

  • Illegal selection of participants for granting a concession
  • Concluding an invalid direct agreement
  • Ineffective concession which creates significant burden of the state budget
  • Absence of specific regulations and policies of concession procedure guidelines.
  • Lack of related administrative authorities’ involvement on selecting, contracting, implementing, or overseeing concession
  • Risk management and risk allocation methodologies

Therefore, the government submitted the first draft of Law on Public-Private Partnership on April 6, 2022, and requested to repeal the Law of Mongolia on Concession. The purpose of the law is to support private sector’s participation and investment in the implementation of public-private partnership in the field of public infrastructure and public services projects, and to create favorable legal environment for long-term efficient cooperation.

Are Uncompleted Buildings Real Estate?



Posted by , , ,

It is common practice for a real estate developer to take an order or advance payment from customer for an apartment building, obtain an uncompleted building certificate from the state registry, and pledge the certificate to a bank or non-bank financial institution and obtain loan in order to finance the project.

According to the State Registration Agency, as of September 30, 2020, 552 uncompleted buildings in Ulaanbaatar were registered as real estate. Of these, 123 uncompleted buildings are pledged as collateral for loans from banks and financial institutions. In addition, there are 333 people who have not been able to obtain a real estate certificate even though the building has been completed and people has purchased the apartment. Moreover, bribery of the General Authority of State Registration in order to obtain a real estate certificate, as well as the creation of a network of bribes through acquaintances, is due to the regulation of registration of uncompleted buildings as real estate.

Therefore, taking into account the above circumstances, Article 10.10 of the Law on State Registration of Property Rights” amended as “An apartment building will not be registered in the state registry of property rights until it is commissioned/ handed over for permanent use” and the amendment was supported by the relevant standing committee and was recently submitted to the plenary session of the Parliament.

It is an important to change the regulations that corrects the practice of registering uncompleted buildings as real estate which violates citizens’ property rights, and creates new regulations related to the rights of public apartment and surrounding land. In addition, the amendments are based on the need to harmonize the Civil Code and the Land Law, including the need to change and improve the regulation of serious violations of citizens’ property rights related to public housing/apartment.

Avoid Risks in Foreign-Mongolian Cooperation Agreements



Posted by , , , ,

Our Mongolian Lawyers regularly assist foreign investors in various forms of joint ventures and business cooperation with Mongolian partners. These partnerships are sometimes necessary to allow a foreign investor to participate where Mongolia law restrictions direct foreign ownership. For example, Mongolian law has certain restrictions on entities with foreign investment owning and using land. One client the firm has worked with, a European party engaged in property development entered into one such arrangement with a Mongolian partner for the development of land located in a special restricted zone of Ulaanbaatar.

The European side, and the Mongolian side entered into a “Cooperation Agreement” which described a cooperative business arrangement in which the European party contributed funding, while the Mongolian party contributed access to the land targeted for development. This type of cooperation, is common in Mongolia between foreign investors and Mongolian property owners, and has been upheld by Mongolian courts.

However, when entering into such an arrangement, a foreign investor should be aware of risks.  A few years into the partnership, relations broke down between the Mongolian party and the foreign investor resulting in extensive litigation over the validity of the Cooperation Agreement and ownership of the land.

Foreign participants in this kind of Cooperation Agreement should engage independent Mongolian legal counsel to review the agreement for compliance with Mongolian law, and to ensure the foreign party is protected. The agreement should be clear about the nature of the cooperation, and the contributions of each party. It is important specify that legal ownership of the land remains with the Mongolian party. To eliminate confusion, there are certain key phrases which should be avoided when describing the foreign investor’s relationship to the land. If the language of the Agreement is ambiguous the Mongolian side may latter attempt to challenge the validity of the Agreement alleging violation of Mongolian law.

Mongolia Passes New Law on Food Enrichment



Posted by , ,

According to the 5th National Survey “Nutrition of the Mongolian population”, the there is a common high deficiency in vitamin and minerals among children and women in Mongolia.

The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends the Government of Mongolia to consume enriched food daily and provide a large portion of the day to day calories by a large proportion of the population.

Therefore, the State Great Khural of Mongolia (Parliament) adopted the Law on the Enriched Food on 03 May 2018, which shall be effective from 31 December 2019.

The food enrichment is aimed at preventing and monitoring vitamin and minerals’ deficiencies among the populations and is a cost-effective and efficient public health measurement.

The Government of Mongolia approved the “List of Mandatory Enrichment Food ” by the Resolution No. 336 of October 31, 2018. According to the resolution, wheat flour, bread flour and salt are required to be enriched. This also applies to flour and salt imported to Mongolia.

According to the WHO recommendation, the enrichment preparation for wheat flour is a combination of vitamins B and D vitamins, iron and zinc. However, salt for food is enriched with potassium iodate (KIO3).

In the framework of the Law on Enriched Food, it is planned to approve the rules of the registration of the enriched food, the creation of its database, the production and storage of fortified foods and the procedures of indicating the enriched food’s emblems and symbols.

Mongolia Passes New Law on Advocacy



Posted by ,

Today, on 18th October 2019, during its Parliament session, the State Great Khural had its final discussion of the draft Law on the Advocacy and other proposed law drafts, and 53.3% voted for the adoption of the Law on Advocacy.

The Law on Advocacy became void in 2012, and there has been no specific law on advocacy or the legal professional since that time. According to supporters of the law, the legal profession has faced severe hindrances since 2012. Even the independent Attorney Association had collapsed, leaving legal professionals in uncertainty as to many aspects of the practice of law.

This new law contains detailed regulations concerning the rights, duties, and professional code of ethics for attorneys, as well as a description of procedures for settlement of potential violations thereof.

This Law on Advocacy shall enter into force from the 01st February 2020.

THE 2019 FALL SESSION OF THE STATE GREAT HURAL



Posted by ,

The 2019 fall plenary session of the State Great Hural started on Tuesday, 1 October 2019 at the State Palace.

At the opening of the fall plenary session, the Speaker of the State Great Khural Mr G.Zandanshatar remarked that only two regular session left for the parliament, formed as a result of the 7th parliamentary election in 2016. There is a spring session in 2020 after this session. Therefore, the fall session of parliament requires to work under the tight schedule and high pressure.

Many bills, draft amendments and resolutions are expected to be discussed and passed by the fall session, especially a draft amendment to the Constitution of Mongolia and a bill on elections must be adopted six months ahead of the next year’s parliamentary election.

In addition, Parliament is scheduled to review around 28 legislative proposals in despite of the resolutions during the autumn session as namely below:

  • Drafts of State budget in 2020,
  • Law on the Legal Status of the Capital City.
  • Draft Law on Legal Status of Cities and Villages;
  • Draft amendments to the Law on Food Supplement and the Law on Food Security;
  • Revised draft to the Law on Family;
  • Revised draft to the Law on Labor;
  • Draft amendments to the Law on Infringement Proceeding;
  • Draft amendments to the Criminal Code;
  • Draft amendments to the Law on Criminal Proceeding;
  • Bill on advocacy;
  • Revised draft to the Law on Tourism;
  • Bill on Transparency in Mineral Resources;
  • Revised draft to the Law on Competition; and
  • Bill on Patriotic Purchasing etc.

The Mongolian Government Going Online



Posted by , , , ,

Mongolia may have a reputation of a sparsely populated nomadic country, but the Mongolian government in increasingly adopting the technologies of the 21st century to reach and serve the people even in the furthest reaches of the steppe. Several major government agencies have implemented systems to provide services online with great success. Foreign investors are able to take advantage of these systems to make doing business in Mongolia more effective and efficient.

The tax authority is one example. In 2014 the tax authority implemented a new online tax filing and tax payment system. A digital signature issued by the tax office is required to access the online tax portal. An individual authorized by a company to sign financial statements and tax returns must apply for a digital signature in order to be able to access the online tax portal system. The online tax filing and tax payments have proven to be more cost and time saving. The social insurance office has taken inspiration from this system and is now also online.

Recently several government bodies, such as Ministry of Finance, Bank of Mongolia, General Tax Administration, National Transportation Department and others, have collaborated and launch a website www.smartcar.mn. Through this site vehicle owners, both individuals and organizations, can pay vehicle taxes, driver’s insurance payments, traffic tickets and receive other vehicle related services.

The General Authority for Intellectual Property and State Registration recently announced that they are in process of preparation and implementation of a “One citizen, one registration” project. According to officials, one of the main purposes of this project is to create a unified national registration database for ownership and property related information of natural personas and legal entities. This project aims to eliminate duplication and discrepancies in information over multiple platforms and create a unified national registration database. Such database is planned to accessible online both for internal access for government bodies as well as to general public with certain limitations. This project envisages the use of digital signatures by individuals to obtain online services from government bodies. Currently, digital signatures used only by legal entities for online tax filing and public tenders (bidding). While this project is in planning stages and has yet to be approved by the Government, we have high hopes for successful implementation. Officials claim that, if this project gets approved, this will decrease the amount of paperwork, will be cost and time saving both for general public and government bodies, government services will be easier, more accessible and closer to general public, and for foreign investors.

At such rate of increasing online government services, it looks like in coming years we should expect less bureaucracy and more accessibility from Mongolian government bodies, which should contribute to increasing economic activity in the developing nation.

Time Running Out for Mongolians to Claim Free Land Entitlement



Posted by , , , , ,

According to Mongolian law, each Mongolian citizen is legally entitled to own a plot of land. Plot size allotted will be depending on the location, which a smaller plot available in Ulaanbaatar, and a larger plot (up to .05 hectares) available in more rural areas This ownership entitlement is a one-time opportunity granted by “The Law on Allocation of Land to Mongolian Citizens for Ownership”. But the opportunity is not forever and the period to apply for a free grant of land in accordance with the law expires on May 1st this year.

As the deadline is fast approaching, our Mongolian lawyers would like to offer some tips on the application process to Mongolian citizens who have not yet taken advantage of the land grant.

Firstly, citizens applying for the land grant must submit applications materials to the local governor or land development office. The Application requirements as set out by law require applicants to submit the following documentation and materials.

Citizens need to submit their application to the relevant local Governor or land department to acquire land for ownership for the purpose of family needs.

  • notarized copies of birth certificates of family members who have not reached 16 years of age
  • letter of confirmation by a Governor of khoroo or bag on the status of the family and number of its members;
  • if land is possessed according to Law on Land, then copies of the land certificate to possess land or notarized copy of the land possession contract;
  • an outlining map showing location and size of the land requested (if the land is to be owned on a shared basis among a group then an outlining map of every parcel belonging to each owner showing its size, location and boundary).

The local governor will review the application documentation and resolve the application within a period of 3 months from receiving the application. Usually the land is granted unless there are irregularities in the documentation. The land grant issued by the governor will indicate the plot’s location, boundaries, purpose, full name of the new owner, the owner’s identification number and birth certificate number for those who have not yet reached 16 years of age.

Based on the decision of Governor, the local Immovable Property Registration Office will register the land ownership status and will issue a registration certificate for immovable property reflecting ownership.